Putin embraces Yalta comparison after Shenzhen talks
Russia’s president welcomed comparisons with the 1945 summit after three-way talks in Shenzhen produced only a vague nuclear-risk pledge.

Shenzhen — Russia’s Vladimir Putin cast a new three-power dialogue in sweeping historical terms after meeting Donald Trump and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen. At the November 19 Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting, the three leaders agreed to begin talks on nuclear risk reduction, according to The Hindu. They offered no details on how the dialogue would be institutionalised.
Speaking to reporters after the summit in the Chinese technology hub, Mr Putin was asked about comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference. He did not dispute the parallel; he welcomed it.
“What was wrong with Yalta? What was so bad about it?” Mr Putin said. “At Yalta, the victory over Nazism was codified... I wouldn’t mind — in fact, I would consider it right — to codify a victory over ‘neo-Nazism’ as well.”
Yalta brought together Joseph Stalin, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Winston Churchill in February 1945, as Soviet forces advanced through Eastern Europe towards Berlin and Allied troops moved from the west. With Nazi Germany’s defeat certain, the three leaders agreed that Germany would be divided, its militarism eliminated and Nazi institutions dismantled. The meeting helped shape Europe’s post-war order.
That history makes the comparison potent, but it also shows what Shenzhen lacked. Yalta produced decisions on the political order after an imminent military victory. The Shenzhen outcome, by contrast, was an opening commitment to discuss nuclear risk. The Hindu reported no details on the machinery, timetable or terms for turning the pledge into a continuing process.
The distinction is practical as well as symbolic. A statement can signal that Washington, Moscow and Beijing want contact; an institutionalised channel determines who attends, how often they meet and which risks are addressed. No such arrangements have been disclosed.
The confirmed outcome is a decision to start talks. The next test will be the first formal announcement of a date, venue and negotiating level. Until then, the trilateral is closer to an opening statement than a new Yalta.
Sources
This article is based on reporting from:


